Share This Article
Welcome to another purchase reflection, where I walk you through my personal thought process when deciding whether to buy a game or not. Today’s subject is Herdling, the atmospheric adventure from Okomotive and Panic that just got a brand-new Nintendo Switch 2 Edition.
I’m in a slightly different spot this time, because I already bought Herdling on day one, back in August 2025. I’ve now played it on the original Switch, on Switch 2 through backward compatibility, and now in its new Switch 2 Edition.
So with a Switch 2 Edition, a free upgrade, and a big discount all landing at the same time, is Herdling finally worth it? Let me guide you through my thoughts so you can decide for yourself.

What Is Herdling?
In Herdling, you guide a herd of big, fluffy creatures called Calicorns out of a city and into the wilderness, in the hope of finding a safe place where they can live happily.
Just like other games in this genre, such as Abzu, this is more of an atmospheric experience, and there’s no dialogue or text to tell you what’s happening. Here, the visuals, music, and surroundings all tell you a story, but leave the interpretation 100% up to the player.
How Long Is Herdling?
When I first played it, it was exactly the type of game I needed to relax after a stressful and tiring week. I sat down on my couch on a Friday night and played it until the end, all in under 4 hours of gameplay.
But is it long enough for the price they’re asking? Well, in games like Journey, Abzu, and Sword of the Sea, this is the norm, and I’m totally fine with it because these games are just perfect. I never finished one of them thinking it should’ve been longer, because the experience they deliver is polished in every single aspect.
And Herdling is just not polished enough to justify the purchase.

The Gameplay Elements
This is a herding game: you control your herd by moving your character to the opposite side of where you want them to go while pressing ZR. I’ll be honest, this doesn’t always feel good, and I can’t quite explain why.
You can also order them to stop and run, pet individual Calicorns, name them, and pray they don’t die while herding next to a cliff or get eaten by a giant bird.
The game does a great job of creating a connection between you and your Calicorns, and I was always happy to find more in the wild to join our ever-growing herd.
Sometimes you’ll need to split up your herd to solve a quick puzzle, or call for help to reach a higher place or push heavy objects.

All the puzzles were super basic and quick to get through, although the sections where I had to navigate my herd carefully were great, and I wish they’d leaned more on that and expanded it with more puzzle ideas.
But of course, the most fun I had with this game was charging through the fields, and the final rush of the game is spectacular. That is, if you don’t run into a bug like I did… I can’t say whether they’ve patched it or not, but I literally clipped through the floor in the final section of the game, which killed the immersion entirely.
It only happened once, though, and it was the only bug I found throughout the entire game. A single bug won’t make me think a game lacks polish.
However, terrible performance that clearly wasn’t shown in the trailer does.
Don’t Buy Herdling on the Original Switch
Do not buy this on Switch 1, please! Even heavily discounted, this game runs poorly on Switch 1.
The Switch 1 just can’t hold a steady frame rate, and the lower resolution and basic textures completely kill any atmospheric immersion this game tries to create.

What makes me mad is that this wasn’t shown in the Nintendo Direct trailer, where the game ran with no issues.
The only way I was able to play this game back then was on my Switch 2, where the performance is noticeably better.
So if you only own a Switch 1 or a Switch Lite, I’d skip this one, or play it somewhere else.
Does the Switch 2 Edition Fix Herdling’s Problems?
I first downloaded the game again on my newly acquired Switch Lite, stomached the terrible performance for a few minutes, and then grabbed my Switch 2, where I had already installed Herdling’s Switch 2 Edition.
I can confidently say that this is a massive upgrade in visuals and performance. I can’t, however, tell you precisely what the target frame rate is, since it hasn’t been disclosed. It does seem to target 30fps, though, and there are still some drops.
They’re minor compared to the Switch 1 version, but there are heavier ones, like at the beginning of Chapter 4, for some reason.
Visually, everything is much sharper, with less blurry textures. Overall though, I still think the game could look a bit better, since it can sometimes look a bit bland.

Is There a Demo for Herdling?
No, there is no Herdling demo on the Nintendo eShop. This still bothers me, and it’s the exact example I used when I argued that every game should have a demo on Switch 2.
I loved the gameplay trailers and bought it blind on day one. Had there been a demo, I would not have purchased it in the state it was in back then.
The good news is that the risk is lower now. With the sale and the free upgrade path for the Switch 2 Edition, you’re paying half the price for a better version of the game, even if it’s not a perfect one.
Should You Buy Herdling on Switch 2?
If you own a Switch 2 and love games like Journey and Abzu, I’d say no.
If you already own Herdling, the free upgrade path is much appreciated, and I thank Okomotive for that, since it feels like an acknowledgment that this game should not have been released on Switch 1 in that state.
For a new potential buyer, I don’t think I can recommend it. Even after replaying the Switch 2 version today, I just get the feeling that this is an “OK” game with some great moments and ideas that need refining.
If you’re still curious about Herdling, my advice is to add it to your wishlist and wait. If it goes on a bigger sale with a few more patches, maybe it will be worth it.
Until then, Journey, Abzu, and Sword of the Sea deliver this same kind of experience with the polish Herdling is still missing.
Thanks for reading, and I’ll be seeing you again next time with brand-new content!
